Skip to main content

Making your Marriage Work

Breaking the Cycle
of Recurring Arguments 

Question 01

My spouse and I seem to argue about the same issues repeatedly without resolving them. How can we break this cycle?
A Fictitious Case

When the Same Argument Keeps Coming Back

David frequently arrived home later than expected because of the demands of his job. Whenever this happened, Sarah would question him about why he was late. David often responded defensively, explaining that he could not always control what happened at work.

Their conversations quickly became arguments. Sarah would accuse David of being inconsiderate while David would complain that Sarah did not appreciate how hard he worked. Sometimes one of them would withdraw from the conversation. At other times, they would continue arguing until both were angry.

The following day, life would return to normal but nothing would have been resolved. A few days later, David would arrive home late again and the same argument would begin.

Apparently, Sarah's problem was not necessarily David's late arrival but his failure to inform her whenever he expected to be late. She worried about his whereabouts and felt that he did not care about her concerns. David, on the other hand, felt that Sarah did not appreciate the pressures he faced at work.

Neither had clearly communicated these underlying concerns. Consequently, they kept arguing about David's late arrival without addressing the real issues troubling each of them.

How to Break the Cycle of Recurring Arguments in Your Marriage

When the same disagreement keeps recurring, repeatedly discussing the visible issue may not resolve it. You need to establish what is actually troubling each of you, change how you discuss it and agree on what each spouse will do differently.

Here are six practices to consider
1. Identify the Underlying Issue Behind the Recurring Argument

Look beyond what normally starts the argument and establish what is actually troubling each of you. Ask yourself:“What is really upsetting me?” Then ask your spouse the same question, before assuming that you already know the answer.

For instance, Sarah could explain: “When you arrive home much later than expected without telling me, I become worried because I do not know whether you are safe. I also feel that my concern is not being considered.” David might then explain:“When I arrive home after a difficult day and the first thing I hear is criticism, I feel that the pressure I am dealing with at work is not understood.” This changes the discussion. Instead of arguing repeatedly about lateness, they can now address communication, concern and the pressure David is experiencing at work.

Therefore, do not assume that the issue you are arguing about is necessarily the issue that needs to be resolved.

2. Discuss the Issue When You Are Both Calm

Do not wait until the problem happens again before trying to resolve it, given that If every serious discussion begins when one spouse is already angry, disappointed or exhausted, you are more likely to repeat the familiar argument than reach a solution.

Sarah could say to David at an appropriate time: “I do not want us to keep having the same argument whenever you come home late. Could we talk about what is happening and agree on how we can handle it differently?”

Therefore, choose a time when both of you can give the conversation appropriate attention. In other words, avoid beginning an important discussion when one spouse is rushing somewhere, extremely tired or already upset about another matter.

If an argument has already become heated, agree to return to the issue when both of you are calmer rather than saying things that will make the disagreement more difficult to resolve. The objective is not to avoid difficult conversations but to discuss in an environment where resolution is more likely.

3. Explain Your Concerns Without Blaming Your Spouse

Clearly state what is troubling you and the effect os that situation on you; without turning the discussion into an attack on your spouse's character. Avoid statements such as: “You never think about anybody except yourself” or“You are always looking for something to complain about.” These statements drive the other person to go on the defensive rather than addressing the problem.

Sarah could instead say: “When I expect you at a particular time and several hours pass without hearing from you, I become worried. I prefer that you let me know whenever you expect to be late.” David could say: “When I come home and the conversation immediately begins with accusations, I feel that's unfair. I would prefer that you first ask me what happened, then I can always explain.”

In other words, describe the behaviour; its effect on you and your relationship; and the change you would like to see. This gives your spouse something specific to respond to.

4. Listen to Understand Your Spouse’s Side or Challenges

Give your spouse an opportunity to explain his or her perspective without immediately preparing a defence. Ask questions to get clarity, should that become necessary. You can also paraphrase before responding. For example, you could say: “So the main problem is not simply that I come home late. You are saying that when I do not communicate, you become worried and feel that I have am taking your concern for granted. Is that what you mean?”

Sarah could similarly establish whether David's defensiveness is arising from the pressure he experiences at work rather than from his failure to communicate with her.

Notice that understanding your spouse's concern does not mean that you automatically agree with everything he or she says; but that you have understood the concern accurately enough to address it. If both spouses spend the conversation proving why the other person is wrong, the argument is likely to continue.

5. Agree on the Specific Changes Each of You Will Make

Do not end the discussion with vague promises such as “We shall try to communicate better.” Rather, agree on what each of you will actually do differently the next time the situation arises.

David might say: “If I realise that I will be home later than expected, I will call or send you a message as soon as I know.” For Sarah, she could say: “If you arrive home late after informing me, I will not begin by accusing you of being inconsiderate. I will raise the matter calmly and be ready to listen.”

In other words, the agreement should address the concerns of both spouses. Therefore, avoid treating resolution as a process in which one person must change while the other continues behaving exactly as before.

Find the root cause of that recurring disagreement. Is it to do with money, relatives, household responsibilities, parenting, intimacy or another matter? Devise ways of addressing the root-cause.  All in all, agree on who will do what, when and under what circumstances to avoid recurrence.

6. Review Whether the Agreed Changes Are Resolving the Problem

Give the agreement an opportunity to work. Be postive and objective. However, do not assume that one conversation will automatically end a disagreement that has been recurring for months or years. Monitoring is healthy and important. Therefore, notice whether each of you is implementing what you agreed upon. Is the frequency and intensity of the arguments reducing?

For instance, If David has been informing Sarah whenever he expects to be late but they continue arguing, the couple should return to the drawing board and establish what they could have missed out. One of them might say: “We agreed on how we would handle this but we still seem to be getting upset about it. What did we ignore when we talked?”

If any or both of you are repeatedly disregarding agreements o, refusing down-to-earth discussions; if the conflict continues to cause serious distress despite genuine efforts to address the issue, you consider seeking appropriate support from a trusted counsellor.

The purpose of reviewing the agreement is not to keep score of who has failed but to determine whether the changes you agreed upon are actually helping you resolve the recurring problem.

Final
Thought

In Closing

Recurring arguments rarely disappear simply because a couple becomes tired of having them. Something in the way the issue is understood, discussed or handled usually needs to change. Therefore, Look beyond the immediate argument, communicate the underlying concern, listen to understand your spouse's perspective and agree on specific changes that both of you can implement.

You begin to break the cycle when you stop merely repeating the argument and start addressing what keeps bringing the argument back

Explore All Programs